Tested: Does This Detergent Alternative Actually Work?

Crystal Wash says it has science on its side, so we put it to the test.

Credit: Reviewed.com / Jonathan Chan
Our editors review and recommend products to help you buy the stuff you need. If you make a purchase by clicking one of our links, we may earn a small share of the revenue. Our picks and opinions are independent from any business incentives.

When we first heard about Crystal Wash, we immediately thought of all those "laundry balls" that appeared on home shopping channels in the 1990s. The majority of these were determined not to work, and given their affiliation with a lot of multilevel marketing schemes it's not surprising.

But the demand for alternative/DIY detergent hacks is very much real, and we're always on the lookout for innovative laundry products. With that in mind, we procured a couple Crystal Wash laundry balls to see if they actually work as advertised.

Eco friendly hero

Related

Green up your laundry this Earth Day with the best eco-friendly detergents

The Claim

On its website, Crystal Wash claims that its laundry balls are filled with bioceramics—the same materials that some hip replacements are made of.

Claims
Crystal Wash claims that its laundry balls increase the pH of water to help get rid of stains. View Larger

The company states that its bioceramics increase the pH of water by 0.6 after only 15 minutes of exposure. This is important because it has been well documented that most bacteria thrive between a pH of 6.5 and 7. So by increasing the pH, Crystal Wash hopes soils will more easily wash away and that your laundry will be disinfected.

At the end of the day, the biggest claim Crystal Wash makes is that the laundry ball will clean your clothes as well as traditional detergents for up to 1,000 washes.

This sounded a little far-fetched to us, but we decided to keep an open mind. If it works, Crystal Wash could revolutionize the laundry industry. After all, anyone who's bought detergent lately has seen that the price just keeps going up. Enough, already!

The Test

In order to really zero in on Crystal Wash's capabilities, we decided to test it in our state-of-the-art labs. The controlled environment accounted for humidity, air temperature, and water temperature. With the extraneous factors out of the way, we decided to pit the Crystal Wash against the most popular brand of store-bought detergent, as well as plain old hot water.

Detergent
Credit: Reviewed.com / Jonathan Chan
We used a standard store-bought detergent to challenge Crystal Wash. View Larger

Stain removal depends on three things: Agitation, water, and chemistry. Anyone whose ever blotted out a food stain from a shirt in a restaurant bathroom knows that different stains require different methods of removal. That's why we used stain strips to quantify how each cleaning agent performed.

These strips are mechanically coated with common household substances like cocoa and red wine, and the three tests were performed with the Kenmore 25132, a top loader very similar to what's found in a lot of U.S. homes. We set the Kenmore to its highest temperature setting and used the Normal cycle.

After each test cycle, we analyzed the stain strips with a photospectrometer to determine how much of the stain had been lifted. Since we know what the color of the cloth is underneath all the stains, we calculated how close the cleaning agents came in restoring the test strips to their native state.

The Results

We came to a solid conclusion: When it comes to stain removal, Crystal Wash does not work any better than hot water. And, when it comes to some important stains, Crystal Wash often works far worse than laundry detergent.

Comparison
On top are the results of the Crystal Wash. When compared to the water-only wash on the bottom, we found that they had the same amount of overall stain removal. View Larger

The hard numbers show that the store-bought detergent did 4 percent better across the board at stain removal than Crystal Wash. Crystal Wash performed about the same as hot water, and from these results we can conclude that Crystal Wash had a negligible effect on stain removal.


However, when we delve into the individual stains themselves, the story gets a bit more interesting. Crystal Wash, water, and detergent all did about the same when it came to removing carbon, blood, and cocoa—meaning that hot water and agitation did most of the heavy lifting.

But on sweat stains, detergent did a whopping 14 percent better at cleaning than Crystal Wash or water. This is, in our opinion, Crystal Wash's greatest failing: Since clothes are worn by people, they almost always get sweat stains. Unless you're okay with wearing dingy shirts with yellowed armpits, you should stick with detergent.

It's understandable that there's a demand for laundry cleaner that doesn't use as many harsh chemicals as detergent. However, each of those chemicals serves a specific purpose in removing stains—especially when it comes to stains like sweat. And although Crystal Wash has none of the chemicals of regular detergent, it has none of the efficacy either. There were high hopes for Crystal Wash as it raised over $250,000 on its Kickstarter, so it's a bit of a bummer that it fails at one of the basic tasks of doing laundry.

To those who paid the $50 for a set: You should return it.

Our editors review and recommend products to help you buy the stuff you need. If you make a purchase by clicking one of our links, we may earn a small share of the revenue. Our picks and opinions are independent from any business incentives.

What's Your Take?

All Comments
Our editors review and recommend products to help you buy the stuff you need. If you make a purchase by clicking one of our links, we may earn a small share of the revenue. Our picks and opinions are independent from any business incentives.
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below
Advertisement - Continue Reading Below